New Insights into Quantum Heat Flow Challenge Conventional Thermodynamics

Recent research led by Professor Aabhaas Vineet Mallik at Bar-Ilan University and BITS Pilani K K Birla Goa Campus has unveiled intriguing patterns of heat flow within quantum computers that contradict classical thermodynamics. By employing mid-circuit measurements, the researchers not only observed this unusual behavior but also provided insights that may pave the way for developing more reliable quantum computing systems.

Traditional computers use transistors to represent data as binary digits—ones and zeros. In contrast, quantum computers operate using qubits, which can simultaneously exist in multiple states. This unique characteristic allows qubits to process information in ways that classical bits cannot achieve. The prevalent architecture for quantum computations is gate-based quantum computing, which uses discrete “gates” to methodically control the state evolution of qubits.

On the other hand, there are quantum systems like those from D-Wave that evolve continuously toward solutions, primarily geared toward optimization problems but limited in their versatility. Mallik emphasizes that gate-based quantum computers are potentially universal, capable of addressing a broader spectrum of computational challenges and integrating seamlessly with classical computing systems.

Investment from tech giants such as IBM, Google, and Microsoft into gate-based designs underscores their long-term aspirations. Such machines could one day simulate complex materials, assist in drug discovery, or analyze protein folding—applications far beyond the reach of current supercomputers.

One of the substantial hurdles in quantum computing is error management. Each quantum algorithm introduces minor errors that can accumulate, corrupting the results. However, measurement in quantum mechanics is inherently disruptive, forcing qubits from a state of uncertainty to a defined outcome. This characteristic complicates the measurement of qubits but also opens up new possibilities.

The research team has explored a promising method called mid-circuit measurement, which involves monitoring qubit states during computations. This strategy not only helps to mitigate error propagation but also offers a novel perspective on quantum thermodynamics.

Traditionally, heat flows from hotter to cooler bodies, as defined by classical thermodynamics. However, the findings indicate that under certain conditions, heat can flow in reverse. This phenomenon, attributed to quantum correlations—subtle linkages unexplainable by classical physics—was made observable through well-designed mid-circuit measurements, as noted by Mallik.

"We have identified a class of quantum computing architectures where the error due to mid-circuit measurements is minimal enough to clearly observe what we call anomalous quantum heat flow," he remarked. The team recognized instances of inverse heat flow, as well as normal heat transfer occurring despite being influenced by quantum correlations. “We unambiguously observed quantum anomalous heat flow,” Mallik stated.

These results are not just theoretical. They're practically significant as they reveal how quantum systems respond to noise and error—critical for enhancing the reliability of quantum machines. Mallik noted, “Characterizing noise from mid-circuit measurements is crucial for developing practical quantum computers.” While many private entities might explore this internally, their study stands out as a rare public contribution to this area.

Academic researchers and public institutions, particularly those focused on superconducting quantum technologies—the most widely applied platform—can leverage these findings to strengthen their studies and applications.

Beyond simply correcting errors, this exploration of quantum heat flow may provide researchers with a benchmark for assessing the “quantum” authenticity of a computer. By measuring for anomalous heat patterns, scientists have a novel technique to validate quantum behavior in machines. Mallik emphasizes potential future developments, suggesting that this approach could become more integral in quantum research methodologies.

The study opens several pathways for deeper inquiry. Mallik and teammates aim to expand their techniques to explore larger quantum systems, comparing various hardware configurations. “We’re considering developing additional quantum thermodynamics protocols to ascertain the quantumness of systems and enhancing noise characterization protocols associated with mid-circuit measurements,” he added.

As advancements in quantum computing continue, researchers face the dual challenge of addressing errors while navigating the complexities of quantum mechanics. This new research highlights the interconnectedness of these challenges, indicating that understanding mid-circuit measurements can illuminate both error management and fundamental quantum principles, ultimately guiding the evolution of future quantum technologies.

Reference: A. V. Mallik et al., Probing Quantum Anomalous Heat Flow Using Mid–Circuit Measurements, Advanced Quantum Technologies (2025), DOI: 10.1002/qute.202500328

Sign up for our newsletter to stay updated on the latest developments in science.

Xiuzhen Yu discusses how advanced microscopy may inform the future of spintronics.

Bridging the gap between physics and materials engineering, Manling Sui is pushing the boundaries of electron microscopy while advocating for more women in the field of physics.

A recipient of the 2026 Nanophotonics Early Career Award, Haoye Qin is working on topology and engineered disorder to create compact optical technologies.